chapter 281: s.4 commentary
Fanfic 11 Comments »“Season Four” was very different from the other seasons of Seeking Happiness. Not only was it the final season — which went on to complete the story — but its format and style of writing was very different from previous seasons. Gone were the heavy dialogues and developments. There were no chapters that existed solely to develop characters and relationships. The action was constant and the story sprinted at light speed. Stories that should have developed other many chapters were done in a few (if not one chapter). The pacing, details, and developments were all sacrificed because I had to finish the story in 3 months. I didn’t think it was possible, but I did it.
Am I happy with the final product? Mostly. I don’t refute that the story was very rushed; at times it was almost anti-climatic and at other times it was somewhat unconvincing (due to its abruptness). Generally though I was able to write most of the stories I had planned for these characters. You’ll get to learn all about the stories (and characters) that were cut due to lack of time in a special “Afterwords” chapter.
The content in season four was enough for two seasons and originally I planned five seasons with at least 400 chapters. Coming at the end of season three there were still many, many stories that I hadn’t written yet. I was “saving” them so that I could spread it all throughout the fanfic’s life so that there would always be something new and interesting to read. I wanted different stories to “lead” and hold the helm of the fanfic at different times. Unfortunately, everything was jammed packed into the last 61 chapters. It was overwhelming to write sometimes because I had “too many” stories. Some characters completely disappeared when the focus wasn’t on them. Big group/family scenes were rare. There was no “down time” ever in season four.
The format of season four hurt the four new main characters — Sek Biu (Raymond Lam), Lam Yuk Fan (Tavia Yeung), Wong Tsz Lok (Bosco Wong), and Chung Ka Ting (Leila Tong) — the most. I failed to properly develop them and thus the audience didn’t feel much for their characters and stories. I didn’t want to devote so much time to them when I still had so many other characters and stories that were already established. As it turns out the audience cares most about the “original” Virtues of Harmony blood and loves to read about them as compared to the new characters. I completely understand. I take full responsibility for “wasting” (even ruining) these new characters.
Originally I planned on introducing the new characters much more gradually and giving them stories to interact with our existing characters. It was supposed to be much more integrated. They were definitely not intended to feel like “outsiders” or “forced” on the audience. Sadly, due to their lack of developments and focus, they were viewed as such.
I have to make a confession. I did not enjoy writing for the new characters as much as I thought I would. Maybe it was because I didn’t get to explore them and therefore never connected to their “hearts”. I didn’t feel for them or enjoy them as much as the existing characters from seasons one through three. I had so much more fun and interest when I didn’t have to write for the new characters. The complaints against the new characters and how their chapters lacked the Virtues “feel” were totally understandable and I also have to agree with the criticisms.
Season four was all about the breakdown of our beloved Kam family and friends. Every story reached a climax and contributed beautifully to the fanfic’s main theme of happiness — which I’ll discuss in depth in the upcoming “special”.
The best single storyline in season four is arguably the entangled love relations among Ah Sing (Hawick Lau), Ah Lam (Linda Chung), Ah San (Steven Ma), and Fiona (Sherming Yiu). It was not surprising to me that it was the most well-received and highly-rated storyline of the season. This story was developed since season one and after over 200 chapters of building up it reached an explosive climax that captivated everyone. Not only was it an exciting, interesting, and “juicy” storyline, but it was also a very meaningful story that resulted in two very touching and sweet endings. I absolutely loved the Ah Sing/Ah Lam/Ah San/Fiona storyline the most. It was extremely satisfying and my best-written story this season.
I was always a fan of Ah Sing & Ah Lam and enjoyed their chemistry. I was intrigued by them. I love how they understand each other and are there supporting and helping one another throughout the whole fanfic (leading up to the climatic Chapter 258: loving ah lam and Chapter 259: unfaithful (an affair)). Their “forbidden” past with all of its unresolved feelings, questions, and ambiguities was very fruitful in terms of potential stories (which explains their abundant screen time). I compare their relationship to Heart of Greed’s Dak Dak Dei & Seung Joi Sum and in fact they at several points also address each other by such nicknames.
Since Chapter 69: keeping the key they began their emotional affair. It was subtle, but their reignited feelings were very clear and with each chapter these feelings grew deeper and stronger. They acted inappropriately (even if they did not do anything “wrong”) and were cheating on their respective spouse. It was no longer friendship.
Ah Sing and Ah Lam are both to blame for their affair and the consequent destructions of their marriage. Neither party is innocent. Ah Sing may have initiated their kiss and brought to surface their “forbidden” (therefore hidden) feelings but Ah Lam returned his kiss. She chose to confide in him and depend on him instead of her husband. This is very wrong and doesn’t constitute a healthy relationship — let alone a marriage.
The affair/cheating issue was something I always wanted to write about because it intrigues me. I believe they start out innocent. I don’t think the majority of cheaters maliciously set out on cheating. It is a mix of unclear feelings and failure to properly handle relationships which result in affairs. Of course when it comes to “love” it is hard to think logically. The heart is hard to control.
The Ah Sing/Ah Lam affair was brilliantly and truthfully written. I am very proud of those chapters; all of the build-up over the last 200 chapters was worth it. I loved it.
Ah San and Ah Lam’s marriage was rocky from the start. He was working too much and then he hurt Ah Lam’s pride and work ethics by bribing clients. They temporarily repaired their relationship but were soon torn apart again by the appearance of Ah San’s supposed cousin Ah Gan (Ron Ng). She didn’t support his decision (though she said she did). The breaking point came when Ah Lam learned that Ah San had selfishly broken her trust by making her pregnant with fake birth control pills.
Due to her emotional state she called for a divorce. After learning from Ah Gan that the problems the two faced were all set-up, Ah Lam thought about getting back with Ah San. However, after seeing his “down” state she decided to use the situation to encourage Ah San to work hard (like in the past). She would get back with him when the time was right.
In every step of their relationship Ah Lam was in “control”. She decided everything and always believed she was right. She never asked Ah San. She only thought about herself. Ah San hit the nail on the head when he pointed out Ah Lam’s flaws. I really liked how the tables were turned and that Ah Lam had to work on correcting herself.
The most innocent party in the whole affair was Fiona. After being written out for awhile due to her insanity (and also to further develop and deepen the feelings between Ah Sing & Ah Lam) she regains her sanity only to be boggled by more palatial drama. Originally the third palatial arc was to be much longer and more in-depth, but because of loss of interest for palatial drama in my part it was extremely trimmed down. Ah Sing’s betrayal and broken promises were unforgivable. She was completely broken when she learned of Ah Sing’s affair and how he called her a “third party”. Their relationship was a “lie” and she was a replacement for Ah Lam in Ah Sing’s heart.
Ah Sing “belongs” to Ah Lam. Their history is too deeply rooted. They could never end up together though. They were destined, but ill-fated. “Ah Sing” therefore could never be with Fiona. He hurt her too much and did not deserve her.
Ah Sing’s “death” and subsequent rebirth as Siu Yuen — someone who existed only for Fiona — was very touching. He knew he had wronged her and didn’t dare to wish for forgiveness let alone for them to get back together. He wanted to make up for all the pain he caused her by fulfilling the promises he had made to her by being by her side for the rest of his life. These were things he should have done from the get-go, but as humans we make mistakes, live, and learn. Through all of his actions as Siu Yuen Ah Sing is able to earn Fiona’s forgiveness and they are able to have a new beginning and get back together with none of the “mess” and “history”. I really love their ending; it was very sweet, meaningful, and moving. I especially love the following lines: She had deemed it irreparable. She thought it was broken without hope of ever being whole again. … With Siu Yuen by her side Fiona mended the Island… and he mended her heart.
Ah San has grown so much not only from season one but also from his first appearance in episode 365 of Virtues II. At the end of chapter 277, so has Ah Lam. It is only after the two of them matured were they able to be parents to their newborn daughter and get back together. Not only did they learn more about themselves but they also learned more on what it means to be married. It was over 200 chapters of self-discovery and maturation for this couple. The events of season four truly tested their marriage and relationship. In the end they were able to renew their love and their relationship became much stronger and more balanced. I really enjoyed their ending; I love Ah San & Ah Lam.
Using “death” as a ploy to get Fiona and Ah San to forgive Ah Sing and Ah Lam seems a bit “easy”, but I think only when faced with the prospect of forever losing someone are we able to look pass anger and realize how much we still love that person. Often when people are hurt they understandably turn their “love” to “hate”. Death may have been the “eye-opening act”, but it is ultimately only through their sincere actions were Ah Sing and Ah Lam able to earn Fiona and Ah San’s forgiveness.
The much anticipated Ah Mei (Cutie Mui)/Ah Yuet (Michael Tse)/Ah Lo (Bondy Chiu) love triangle finally happened in season four. I had a lot of fun writing this. The set-up with the triangle was well-done because both girls could be seen as the “third party”. It was an innocent triangle and quite painful.
Ah Lo has always been Virtues’s VIP. She is a crucial “voice” and character in the series (the series noticeably loses entertainment value without Ah Lo). I debated a long time whether or not it was worth it to “kill” her off for the sake of writing the triangle. In the end I felt it was necessary. Despite her 30 chapters absence Ah Lo’s presence was always felt. I really missed her.
When Ah Mei returned she had a complete make-over and thought that her feelings for Ah Yuet were gone. She really did believe that. It wasn’t until she saw how broken he was following Ah Lo’s “death” did her love for him reawaken. She couldn’t ignore him — this is the man she has loved since childhood. With Ah Mei’s endless support, encouragement, help, and love Ah Yuet was able to stand up again. She brought him back to life.
I really grew to love Ah Yuet & Ah Mei. Their relationship was very sweet. It was a refreshing feeling compared with Ah Yuet & Ah Lo’s relationship. Their relationship was rushed and I would have liked to expand and more gradually write their love story but due to the time crunch I was forced to make their relationship so sudden. Ah Yuet & Ah Mei’s relationship, even in the ancient version, has always been based on gratitude and “responsibility” which then spun into love.
I wanted Ah Yuet not only to have a love triangle but to actually have two wives like in the ancient version.
Having Ah Mei discover the truth about Ah Lo was how I always planned it. It was a very tough decision to make, but we all knew what Ah Mei would do. Ah Mei’s “one day of selfishness” was sad and touching.
I love how Ah Yuet classified his relationship with his “two wives” as being one of sourness and the other sweetness. It really summarizes Ah Yuet & Ah Lo’s and Ah Yuet & Ah Mei’s relationships in both modern and ancient times perfectly.
The resolution to Ah Yuet’s love triangle was set from the beginning. It is the same ending the writers originally planned for Virtues II. Ah Mei was always going to sacrifice and leave, offering her full blessings for Ah Yuet & Ah Lo — allowing them to reunite. I love the letters that Ah Mei wrote; they were so sincere and moving. Ah Mei is such a sweet and lovable character; I actually grew to love her character a lot more because of my fanfic (her stories were rather boring in the series).
Ah Yuet loved both Ah Lo and Ah Mei, but they were different types of “love”. Love stories come in many different types and lengths, but it doesn’t make the love any less great. Moving on with life after a spouse dies is really difficult and for a number of people they cannot get over the hurdle of wanting to remain “faithful”. Men generally remarry more often than women. I went over the issue of widows versus widowers but was only able to do so in a superficial manner. I would have loved to dig deeper into that story. Ah Yuet grew to love his two wives, but only Ah Yuet & Ah Lo can be husband and wife in this lifetime.
Gam (Louis Yuen) and Ying Gei’s (Yvonne Lam) pregnancy storyline was drastically trimmed. It was supposed to be a hilarious story watching them try to get pregnant. I originally was going to write a new character for their surrogate. Not wanting to further bloat my already extensive cast I instead decided to incorporate Ah Lo into their story. It was a hilarious twist and tied the story really well together, especially with the impact of Ah Lo’s “accident”. They were able to get pregnant in the end because they stopped trying so hard. I believe that fate will naturally run its course. Sometimes you get what you want when you don’t try so hard. If it is meant to happen… it will.
Ah Yat (Joyce Chen) and Ah Hong (Johnny Tang) sadly never had any stories of their own besides season one’s “pregnancy scare”. It’s not because I don’t like them. Actually I did plan a nice story for them (which I will reveal in the “Afterwords”) but due to how the story turned out, they had to be cut. There wasn’t any story truly worth telling with them. Ah Yat has always had a problem with Ah Lo because she falsely blames her for ruining her chance to be a top TVB actress. They always argue but deep down I think Ah Yat likes having Ah Lo in her life. Even though Ah Yat regretted how she treated Ah Lo after her “death” and wished she was alive to be with her brother, when her “good sister” Ah Mei gets together with Ah Yuet, of course she’s going to support that pair. Ah Yat has always been a cheerleader for Ah Mei & Ah Yuet and always encouraged Ah Mei to “fight” with Ah Lo. Given Ah Yat’s nature, it’s not at all irrational that she childishly “hated” her brother along with Ah Lo in protest for Ah Mei.
After ending up together at the end of season two, Ah Nin (Frankie Lam) and Joey (Bernice Liu) began to take a “back seat” as do all happy couples in series. I would have liked their wedding to be a much bigger event, but due to time constraints they got engaged and married all in one chapter. Still, it didn’t make their wedding any less beautiful. Joey lost her memories after their first kiss. Therefore I always planned on having Ah Nin regain his memories after they kissed again. I admit that it’s a little farfetched that they did not kiss again until their wedding day, but it’s so much more meaningful that way. They got together again because they fell in love again. Ah Nin remembering their past only augments their present happiness. I really love this couple and am thrilled that I was able to give them a beautiful and complete love story in my fanfic.
Man Gwai Fei (Stephanie Che) has always been one of my most favorite characters. She is TVB’s most entertaining villain. Virtues II failed to fully utilize her which was a shame. Thus I couldn’t let her go to waste in my story. I planned to have Gwai Fei come front & center as the hilarious antagonist everyone loves to hate. Actually I feel sorry for Gwai Fei and Chapter 223: birthday, party, tears exemplifies why. She’s so lonely and just wants friends and family. Her attempt to be a “good person” was hilarious because it was so fake and half-hearted. One has to wonder… if Gwai Fei truly wanted to change and be a “good person”, how different would her life end up? Chapter 224: lady vengeance, which marked Gwai Fei’s “turn” into a full-blown villain, was both sad and chilling. She became so caught up in revenge that she lost herself.
Gwai Fei’s schemes did not dominate the story as much as I originally envisioned. Aside from plotting to marry Wong Sheung (Lau Dan), causing Ah Lo’s “death”, causing Joey’s miscarriage, and teaming up with Ah Ting, she really didn’t do much else. Maybe it’s because it’s harder to conduct crime in the daylight of modern times. Maybe it’s because I didn’t have enough time to write or think her villain path thoroughly. All I know is that in the end I still felt like Gwai Fei wasn’t as central a character as I had wanted her to be. Her terrorizing the Kams wasn’t as big as I hyped it to be.
Ah Ting was the new “bad girl” that replaced Rose (Kenix Kwok) in the Kam household. As the beautiful and seemingly innocent god-daughter of Nim Chi (Nancy Sit), Ah Ting was supposed to be the surprising element that helped to further divide the Kams. I did not originally plan on teaming Ah Ting and Gwai Fei together, but it worked out wonderfully. Gwai Fei’s original partner-in-crime was Man Gwai Yan (Celine Ma). I enjoyed Chapter 278: conscience because it really distinguished Ah Ting and Gwai Fei. They are both “villains” but they differed because one still had a “heart”.
Gwai Fei suffered because her heart was closed to everyone. No one could come in because she didn’t let anyone in. She erred and continued to err even when she learned her rape had been a misunderstanding. It’s sad, but Gwai Fei has no one to blame but herself.
My most favorite story to write in terms of the “new” characters was Wong Hau (Maggie Shiu) and Ah Lok. I love “pretty mom” and “handsome son”! They have this undeniable chemistry and charm that is so Virtues. I enjoyed their unique relationship and characterizations tremendously. It was extremely refreshing and fun to write. Out of all the “new” families, my favorite is the Wong family — too cute! I love the happy ending for them.
The most ridiculous story was Ah Biu & Ah Fan. They had a lot of chemistry but sadly I ruined them with a trashy storyline. It just didn’t work out like I had planned. In my mind Ah Fan being wrongly accused as the “third party” (like her mom) was much more touching and the story with Ah Biu helping her realize her dream much sweeter. In reality, it was rather boring and forced. I ended up having to quickly write them off to save them from further destruction. Their stories with their birth parents were interesting and touching, but after that it just went downhill. I feel badly about it.
Going back to the Kams, how much do we love them? It hurt me to break them up and see them really argue and fight “for real” in season four. There were just so many misunderstandings and villains causing troubles that the family split apart. Of course the person who hurt the most because of the breakdown was no other than our main matriarch Nim Chi. In the ancient version Nim Chi was so much more central to the family. She kept everyone and everything in order (despite being crazy and silly herself). This element of Nim Chi was lacking in her modern counterpart which wasn’t right. It was sad watching her run around trying to put the pieces of her family back together.
How typical and tacky is it to have a character fake illness to achieve something? It’s such a predictable cheap trick from TVB writers. The family getting back together because Nim Chi has cancer was something that people expect from TVB. However, there’s a big twist in my story using this same plot device. At the end it’s not clear whether Nim Chi is really sick with cancer and if so, how sick. It’s a cruel twist that’s shocking and unexpected. I purposely ended the story mysteriously and ambiguously.
My most favorite chapter in the entire fanfic has to be the finale: Chapter 280: happiness. It is flawless and completely satisfying. I am so proud of it. It was so well-written, meaningful, touching, and brought back so many memories. It is how Virtues should have ended. It ties the story together beautifully and brings everything full-circle. I love the ending monologue the most. I also love how the very last scene directly relates back to the ending scene of the costume version (which in turn tied it to the modern version). It really connects the entire Virtues saga.
As a whole season four was a jam-packed ride with a ton of action. It concluded and wrapped up the story well despite a few bumpy parts that could have been improved had I had more time. I am by and large satisfied and happy with my work.































Recent Comments