Afterwords
Fanfic 5 Comments »Over four years in the making, Seeking Happiness (Virtues of Harmony III) was a fanfic that ran from 2005-2009 for more than 270 chapters. It started as a result of my dissatisfaction for the incomplete ending that TVB gave fans of the beloved long-running classic which captured hearts since 2001. It was also my hope that by the time I finished my fanfic there would be Virtues again. Five years later [after the series' end] TVB is without “happiness” but thankfully Virtues fans (at the very least me) can have some closure thanks to my story.
It’s been a wonderful and very fulfilling ride. I take great pride in my fanfic. I don’t mean to blow my own horn, but there are just so many great scenes and stories. Actually I plan on revising my story to correct inconsistencies, rewrite certain parts, and add/delete certain things someday. I hope to one day own my fanfic as an actual book. Leave a comment if you want to buy a copy!
I really have to thank TVB for creating such colorful characters and making such a thoroughly entertaining and charming series as Virtues. What other series [in recent years] can we say we “know” the characters? What other series can we recognize the “tone” and “voice” so well? Virtues is just that special. These characters come to life to and for us. I wouldn’t have been able to write so much and so long for any other series. Virtues has my heart always.
My fanfic is a much more dramatic than the actual TVB series (even though I try to maintain Virtues’s authentic “tone” and “feel”). It combines elements of many different genres and has a multitude of characters and stories, allowing the fanfic to remain entertaining, fresh, and interesting. My most favorite series blend genres together so I tried to mimic that with my story.
Actually Virtues II failed to maximize its potential because the script was changed and revised due to casting issues. Characters were wasted and for many episodes in the middle the series remained “static”; it didn’t really go anywhere. I feel great loss because the series could have been so much better [than what it was]. It had an amazing plot originally outlined at the start but sadly the writers didn’t have a chance to see their plans come to life. Luckily I was able to incorporate some of the “original” storylines in my fanfic.
The “original” Virtues II
The information from TVB’s official websites for their series actually doesn’t come from the finalized script. Luckily for us it doesn’t otherwise the world would never be able to learn how “epic” and amazing Virtues II was supposed to be. I’ll summarize the major plot points that I read.
– Ah Lo (Bondy Chiu)/Ah Yuet (Michael Tse)/Ah Mei (Cutie Mui) triangle — Ah Mei had a crush on Ah Yuet ever since they were kids. Unfortunately her meek and timid nature prevented her from “confessing” and therefore Ah Lo swept in and “stole” Ah Yuet. Ah Mei was always supposed to be friends with Ah Lo and silently support and love Ah Yuet. After Ah Lo and Ah Yuet got married they were going to have lots of misunderstandings (each one getting bigger each time and pushing closer to divorce). Eventually the two of them grow apart. Once they got into a heated fight because Ah Lo threw out Ah Yuet’s precious toys.
A “fake” divorce becomes a real one due to coincidences.
During this time Ah Mei and Ah Yuet grow closer and he begins to notice her/love her, finally learning that she has been in love with him for all those years. At the same time Ah Lo misses Ah Yuet and wants him back. She discovers that Ah Mei has “secretly” been “seducing” Ah Yuet. She feels betrayed. Two “sisters” become sworn enemies. Ah Yuet is stuck in the middle not knowing who to choose. [According to Cutie, the eventual ending of the series would be that her character decides to sacrifice and withdraws herself from the triangle. Ah Mei leaves Hong Kong and offers her blessing to Ah Yuet & Ah Lo so they can get back together.]
I hate love triangles (especially TVB’s) but this triangle is so well-crafted! Both girls can be seen as the “third party”. It had great potential for comedic and dramatic storylines. I feel it is such a big loss to the series that the triangle never materialized. I don’t blame Cutie for leaving the series. The writers were wasting her talent with boring stories. They waited too long to kick the triangle into full gear and they didn’t deliver the change to Ah Mei’s character that they were supposed to do [to make her more outspoken and "funny" like in the ancient version]. I feel so sad thinking about never being able to watch this huge story because I personally love Ah Lo/Ah Yuet/Ah Mei. Why, oh why didn’t the writers just write what they planned so intricately?! I’ll never understand.
– Man Gwai Fei (Stephanie Che) was always supposed to be the big antagonist. At first she hates Ah Nin (Frankie Lam) but later grew to love him. Sadly for her he rejects her. She discovers that he has been secretly dating Joey (Bernice Liu). Because she can’t have him she plots to destroy him. She marries Wong Sheung (Lau Dan) to become his boss and not only fires him but slanders him. With a tainted reputation Ah Nin cannot find another job. Most likely her hate would transfer to the rest of the Kams as the series went on.
It’s no secret that I love Man Gwai Fei. She is my absolute most favorite “villain” in TVB history. Stephanie is an amazing comedic actress that is so underrated and underutilized. The original Man Gwai Fei plot sounds so great and hilarious. I really wish we could have watched it.
– Ah Nin and Joey had an incredibly sweet and touching story originally. While Ah Nin was “down” (from being fired at “Ka Yan” and suffering a bad reputation) Joey supported him and helped him to get back on his feet. Thanks to Joey Ah Nin comes back and saves “Ka Yan”.
Who doesn’t love Chris & Joey? I still get angry thinking about how TVB totally ignored their existence and left their relationship hanging.
– Lau Gam/H5N1 (Louis Yuen) was supposed to be a “villain” of sorts. He was supposed to bring “danger” to the family and team up with Man Gwai Fei in helping to hurt/slander Ah Nin.
H5N1 was hilarious but I would have loved to see Lau Gam be a semi-villain.
– Wan Ying Gei (Yvonne Lam) was supposed to marry into the family. Sa Sa (Kingdom Yuen) and her were supposed to be fighting a lot after she moves in and lives with the Kams. Gradually they make amends and become sisters again.
Why was Ah Lo & Ah Yuet the only marriage we got? I really wanted to see everyone get married! The original Wan Ying Gei/Sa Sa story sounds hysterical.
– Ah Yat (Joyce Chen) and Ah Hong (Johnny Tang) had a fantastic love story planned. Ah Yat’s acting career actually picks up and she becomes a rising star. For the sake of Ah Yat’s stardom, Ah Hong sacrifices himself and pretends to be gay and her “sister” — hiding their relationship from the public. In the end Ah Yat has to choose between her career and love.
How touching and meaningful a love story! I really don’t understand why they didn’t do this. Both actors were present and deserve this great story.
How incredible does the original Virtues II sound? It’s really too bad…
Moving back to my fanfic, I enjoyed writing the dialogues the most because it allows me to personally envision the Virtues cast acting out the scenes that I write. I can “hear” their voices reading my lines and “see” their acting. It’s a surreal feeling and in a way the series continues to live for me (and readers) in this way.
When I first started writing, I only had the “big picture” in my head of what I wanted to accomplish. I didn’t know the “small stories” or how I would get to the final destination(s). I actually had the ending to the story planned right from the start. Yes, back in 2005 I already knew how I wanted it to end. I knew I didn’t want a clichéd “happily ever after” ending that people expect from sitcoms. While I love happy endings and it’s great to see our favorite characters happy (after all, the series is called “everyone is happy”) but I wanted something memorable — something long-lasting with an impact. I really wanted to tie up the series in a way that fans could be happy and could “let go”.
Part of the frustration of being a fan of a series that ends too early or ends poorly is that we fail to achieve “closure”. Closure is so important for us as people. Without it we can’t move on.
The theme of the series
The reason I chose to title the series Seeking Happiness is because the theme of my story from the start has been about “happiness” — Virtues’s selling point.
In life we all seek “happiness”; it drives us. The ending monologue is probably my most favorite piece to write in the whole fanfic. It ties up the series so well and really hits the “happiness” theme right in the heart.
Happiness — everyone seeks it. We all want it… it drives our lives.
Some people never get it…
[Shot of Man Gwai Fei in her prison cell]
They don’t get it not because they don’t deserve happiness. They don’t get it because their hearts are closed. Happiness can only enter an open heart.
Some people think they lost it…
[After leaving Hong Kong Ah Mei learned that she was pregnant. She ended up giving birth to a girl. Even though she could not be with Ah Yuet she was able to always have a part of him by her side. Ah Yuet and Ah Mei at one time were able to connect and produce the miracle that is their daughter. Ah Mei valued and loved this girl - who was her everything. This girl represented her undying love for Ah Yuet and the love that Ah Yuet once had for her. Ah Mei and her daughter were a happy mother & daughter pair living in England.]
Instead, they find happiness in another form.
[Shot of Ah Mei kissing her daughter and remembering Ah Yuet]
Life is full of wonderful surprises and twists…
[Shot of Wong Sheung, Wong Hau, and Ah Lok attempting to cook a meal together with 7th sister in the background shaking her head]
Couples always face winds and clouds…
[Flashback of Fiona & Ah Sing's and Ah San & Ah Lam's confrontations]
If they love each other and both grow, they’ll always end up together…
[Shot of Ah Biu and Ah Fan and their families discussing their wedding]
Through it all true love prevails and makes everyone stronger.
[Shot of Ah San & Ah Lam taking pictures of their daughter; shot of Ah Sing pushing Fiona on a swing in the Imperial Garden]
Laughter, laughter…
[Shot of the "Ka Yan" employees gossiping]
The sounds of happiness…
[Shot of the Kam family at a family portrait photo shoot]
Never changing, always the same…
[Shot of the Kam family having dinner at their new house]
Happiness comes unexpected…
[Shot of Ying Gei learning that she's pregnant with Gam's baby]
You can always recognize it…
[Shot of Ah Yuet & Ah Lo and their four kids]
Within the heart…
[Shot of Ah Nin & Joey playing with baby Hoi Sum]
It resides…
[Shot of Ah Yat & Ah Hong]
Forever more…
[Shot of Sa Sa & 11th brother and their adopted daughter Ling-ling]
Sadness…
[Flashback of Rose & Michael's deaths, Ah Lo's presumed death, Ah Ting's murder, and other sad moments throughout the series]
Sadness always exists along with happiness. The two will always go together, always balancing one another. One cannot exist without the other. In sadness there is happiness and in happiness there is sadness.
[Shot of Nim Chi laughing with her family and then secretly going for treatment]
Happiness cannot be sought. It’s not guaranteed. Happiness is earned. Happiness makes life beautiful and worth living.
I always read this excerpt and picture the “ending” playing out in my head. It’s so perfect. It feels complete. It is how Virtues II should have ended (especially with the nod back to the ancient version [since the modern version opened with a "dream" depicting the past]).
What I originally wanted…
In 2005 the ending not only had Nim Chi (Nancy Sit) conclusively dying but also had the entire cast gathering around her grave a few years later to remember her and “thank” her for sacrificing for everyone’s happiness. I decided against this for multiple reasons.
1) Too melodramatic, clichéd, and untrue to Virtues
2) Too forced and unbelievable
3) It makes me too sad to kill a Virtues character, especially Ma Chi
4) I really didn’t want to leave the series with a “sad” ending and I knew fans would hate me if I did (I would hate myself too)
The reason why I had this ending in mind was not because I wanted “shock” value. It was because originally my take on happiness was that someone has to be sad in order for someone else to be happy. The line I had in mind was something like “Happiness comes at the expense of others”. My original thinking for this was in relation with contests (i.e. winners & losers). I recognized this to be faulty and ridiculous so I quickly rewrote the ending to make it ambiguous and leave it for personal interpretation. The theme is more profound this way.
Happiness & sadness are its own entities and exist in a delicate, balanced relationship. They shape life.
My most favorite
– All of the Kam family/group scenes; the chemistry oozes and glows through the words. It really makes me miss the Kams!
– Rose (Kenix Kwok) — my most favorite character to write for; love the complexity and multiple layers of her story and character
– Ah Sing (Hawick Lau)/Ah Lam (Linda Chung)/Ah San (Steven Ma)/Fiona (Sherming Yiu) love square — love the drama; very powerful and touching
– Ah Nin & Joey — so great to see them falling in love again and finally have their happy ending
– Ah Lo/Ah Yuet/Ah Mei love triangle — so good! I really wish the triangle could have been longer
– The Wong family — cute, charming, hilarious; “pretty mom” and “handsome son”!
Deleted stories
– Ah Biu (Raymond Lam) was supposed to be really close with the Kams (especially Nim Chi); Nim Chi adored him because he’s a policeman and reminds her of her younger days as a policewoman — they had plenty to talk about. Ah Yuet & Ah Yat (and the others) got jealous of him and tried to “sabotage” their relationship. In the end Ah Biu wins everyone over and he becomes a welcome fixture at “Tung Mat Yuen”
– A hilarious parody/spoof of War and Beauty; Joey, Ah Lo, Ah Yat, and Ying Gei (the “four concubines”) fighting each other for the affections of Nim Chi (the “emperor”) for the title of “Best Daughter-in-Law”
– Ah Yat returning to acting and getting her “big break”; she gets popular by starring in a costume sitcom ala Virtues. The twist is that it’s a “show within a show”; ancient Virtues comes to life again and we get to see the cast acting out their ancient counterparts again picking up where episode 327 left off
– Ah Tai (Kate Tsui) was going to enter Miss Hong Kong and from this get into acting at TVB (cut due to lack of time to write another “big” story). Would have spoofed beauty pageants and acting in TVB; Ah Yat and Ah Tai become “frenemies”
– Back in season 1 Ah San had a secretary Yoyo (Nnadia Chan) who he was close to; Ah Lam was to misunderstand that he was having an affair (an idea planted by Ah Gan (Ron Ng)). The original Ah Gan “scheme” was a lot more elaborate
– Rose’s father, Mr. Suen (Michael Miu), was going to have heaven’s retribution in a plot connected with Ah Ting (Leila Tong); Rose’s name was to be cleared
– Fiona was going to have a secret younger brother played by Sammul Chan who had been raised by Doctor Tsui (Gallen Lo) outside of the palace; he was going to play a role in helping Fiona get back the Island and would eventually be the Island Chief (Fiona was going to give up the throne to live in Hong Kong)
– Melissa Ng originally had a guest starring role as Fiona’s doctor at the psychiatric hospital; she would become acquainted with the Kams (leading to a hilarious small story that would have concluded with everyone thinking they had mental issues)
– Ah Fan (Tavia Yeung) was going to work at “Tung Mat Yuen” as a waitress and become acquainted with everyone through her job there
– Ng Sau (Albert Lo) was supposed to have a gay twin brother (as a nod to his hilarious gay eunuch role Ling Gong Gong from the ancient version) who worked at Chan Hung’s (Sheren Tang) beauty clinic
– Gam and Ying Gei’s “pregnancy” storyline was going to introduce and involve Ying Gei’s younger sister (who is the complete opposite of her sister) as the surrogate [this role of course went to Ah Lo]
– Nim Chi and Ng Sau’s misunderstanding was going to be resolved
– Joey and Ah Nin’s “parenting” storyline with baby Hoi Sum
There were more stories I had originally planned on writing but have since forgotten. As you can see I had many, many ideas but a lot of it was cut due to lack of time and not knowing how to develop the stories. The other problem was that I had a lot of quirky comedic plots in mind (very Virtues) but it is impossible to capture physical/visual humor in words so I could not write them.
Thank you to all of my readers for your support of this story over the last five years. I know I didn’t make it easy to follow and read because of the frequent and long “breaks”. To those who did not give up and continued to read — thank you. To those who just read a chapter — thank you. To those who commented — thank you. It means a lot that you guys took the time to read.
I hope you guys enjoyed reading as much as I enjoyed writing [and reading too]. It’s been a great couple of years. May we always remember Virtues of Harmony and hold it (even if it’s just a tiny piece) in our hearts.


























Recent Comments