
TVB’s most intelligent series of the 21st century thus far has got to be the 2004 classic
War and Beauty. No other series can compare to the sheer brilliance of this Qing-dynasty costume drama about the dark lives of the concubines living in the palace.
War boosted the audience’s confidence that TVB can still produce high-quality and intellectual programming that is different and not formulary or reused.
Unlike most other TVB series, War is complex, has multiple layers in both its characterizations and plotline, and is so cleverly and well thought out and planned. War is deeply meaningful, intriguing, poignant, and offers much to think about and discuss. It is an artwork — a true masterpiece that TVB can be proud of for many, many years to come. My full review for War is available here.
Obviously, TVB wants to “recreate” the success and magic that was War.
Since 2004, TVB has tried to create other “versions” of War.
Trials and failures
At the end of 2004, Producer Mui ambitiously set out to create a 1930’s version of War revolving around a family who owns a cosmetic shop. That was her goal with 2005’s grand production The Charm Beneath. Charm boasted a very big and impressive cast, including War alumni Gigi Lai & Moses Chan, Yoyo Mung, and Anne Heung.
Just like War, Charm was also 30 episodes and would also be female-dominated, focusing on the power struggles in a rich family in the 1930’s. Charm had everything going for it — a promising premise that was indeed War-like, a beautiful cast, gorgeous, custom-made costumes, and many alluring props and sets. TVB had so much confidence in the series that it was aired as an “Anniversary Series”.
Perhaps TVB made a mistake from the get-go when the English title was revealed to actually be The Charm Beneath rather than Beneath The Charm (there was a bit of confusion because of the way TVB set the words on the poster). The Charm Beneath suggests “finding beauty in ugliness”… rather clichéd. Beneath The Charm would have made for a much more intriguing title because it suggests that the “charm” and allure is deadly [i.e. there's more than meets the eye] — which was exactly what TVB was promoting the series as. In fact, the tagline was something along the lines of “Hiding daggers behind smiles”. This would have fit much better with the theme of the series.
Unlike War, Charm did not win big ratings. In fact, ratings were mediocre and disappointing, especially for the amount of money and promotion that TVB put into the production. Somehow, the audience just wasn’t buying that the series was the 1930’s War. The audience wasn’t hooked into the storyline like they had been for War and Charm did not gain much recognition.
While Charm was one of the best series of 2005 (it’s personally one of my favorites and I deem it a classic), it failed to live up to its goal to be the 1930’s War. The series was said to focus on scheming women fighting for power ala War, but instead, it turned out to be more like a big family drama focusing on kinship, friendship, and love. Fights and struggles happened within the family, but it wasn’t solely the women. The big villain of the series [who propelled much of the plot] was female and the series was female-dominated, but the script was not like a 1930’s War at all. The series was not dark and twisted and the dialogues were also not impressive like in War.
Thus, Charm tried to be a 1930’s War, but failed.
Meanwhile, during 2005, the producer of War was hard at work at his own 1930’s version of War. He reunited the War cast (minus the extraordinary talents of Sheren Tang & Maggie Cheung) and added new main cast members Ada Choi and Maggie Shiu for a very hyped-up, grand production known as The Dance of Passion.
Dance was about the struggles between two clans and focused on the pitiful fates of women. Set in a village secluded from the rest of China, the setting of Dance was a repressive and cruel environment of unjust customs. The four leading female characters all faced many problems and became manipulative and scheming in order to survive (gain some power) and escape their “fate” ala War.
TVB filmed the series on-location in China. Like War, Dance was a high-value grand production that TVB invested a lot into. While Charm failed in 2005 to be another War, people were sure that Dance would live up and be another War since it was from the same production team.
With high hopes comes high disappointment.
Dance’s opening week earned high ratings (mostly because TVB promoted the heck out of it months and months before it released), but this quickly faded as word-of-mouth about the series became unfavorable. The audience complained that Dance was boring and slow. They criticized the yellow tinge that TVB used to give the series a “dry” feel as hurting the eyes. They criticized the long, complicated, drawn-out dialogues full of “meaning”. Thus, the audience wasn’t satisfied with Dance and were not drawn into it like they had been with War. For much of its run, the ratings for Dance was only mediocre for the amount of promotion and money that TVB put into it.
Indeed, Dance was a disappointing series. It had the makings to be a 1930’s War, but failed because it tried too hard. War prides itself in its complex, deep, and intelligent dialogues consisting of only proper and traditional language (which makes it hard for some people to interpret). Dance tried to continue this by also having complex and deep dialogues for its characters. The problem was that the dialogues simply tried too hard. Most of the dialogues seemed excessive and unnecessary, almost running around in a circle before a point was even made. The long, poetic dialogues and slow pace of the series bored some audience members.

Furthermore, the audience could not relate to
Dance’s story. While HK OL’s (office ladies) related themselves to the plight of the
War concubines, they could not put themselves into the shoes of the
Dance women. The fact that
Dance’s setting was in an atypical environment (a secluded village in the desert away from the rest of China) also made it harder to relate. The storyline was also very dramatic [perhaps too melodramatic and "depressing" for some people]. Consequently,
Dance did not draw a big following or crowd like
War and failed to impress. Thus, Producer Chik failed at creating a 1930’s
War.
There’s a saying that the harder you try to do something, the less ideal the results are (hence the comment of “trying too hard”). Sometimes not trying and letting things happen naturally is the best way. Producer Mui and Producer Chik both aspired and tried their best to make 1930’s versions of War, but they did not succeed. Maybe War is a once-in-a-lifetime masterpiece that cannot be recreated. Perhaps its level is so high that it cannot be reached by TVB again. Or…
War comes when least expected.
TVB was able to successfully produce two “versions” of War without trying.
The male version of War
Almost everyone wrote off 2006 series Safe Guards from the very beginning. It was thought to be a doomed production with low viewership because the cast did not consist of anyone “popular” and especially because the female side had then-horrible Elaine Yiu leading. Who knew Safe was not only a good, but an excellent series?

Safe’s male cast is solid, consisting of
Steven Ma,
Wayne Lai,
Cheung Chi Kwong, veteran
Kwok Fung, and
Evergreen Mak. It boasts the strongest acting by a male ensemble in a long time, which is appropriate because the series is male-dominated. It’s rare for TVB to make a male-oriented series and even rarer for such a production to be successful.
Safe managed to be this production. It garnered many praises and relatively high ratings.
Safe ended up being the “male version” of War. War was female-dominated and put issues that women face on center-stage. Likewise, Safe, being a “male version”, was male-dominated and focused on issues that men face. These issues included brotherhood between “real” brothers [blood-related and adopted] and friends, relationships between fathers and sons, and basically roles and responsibilities that men have and what struggles and conflicts comes along with them and how they deal with these issues. It was a truthful portrayal and made the series relatable (even if the time period and actual storylines were not).
Just like War, the script for Safe is top-notch. The dialogues are wonderfully written and there are many powerful scenes. The characterizations are complex and the storyline is engaging. While Safe isn’t dark and intriguing like War, it is still an excellent series and is the most appropriate series worthy of being classified as War’s “male version”.
The 1920’s version of War

2008 series
The Silver Chamber of Sorrows had a low budget and a not-so-grand cast, but TVB had confidence towards this series. They rushed the production and released it the same time that 2007’s huge series
Heart of Greed aired, hoping that
Chamber would be the “costume version” of
Heart. They promoted the series as the ancient
Heart.
Chamber started off rather low in terms of ratings with criticism saying that the series was clichéd and boring. It appeared that
Chamber would not live up to the label of an “ancient
Heart” as TVB was promoting. It also seemed like
Chamber would travel down the road of lowly-rated
Charm.
However, something very surprising happened in its third week of airing. The series picked up and started to receive good buzz. The ratings followed suit. In the final week of airing, the series earned a very respectable rating of 34 pts and peaked at a very impressive 42 pts. Thus, the series started off low but ended on a commendable high and is therefore considered a “success”. Chamber ended with a very good word-of-mouth as many people praised the script. It was a surprising hit in both ratings and quality.
Although TVB classifies Chamber as a costume version of Heart, I think it is much more appropriate to label it the 1920’s version of War. Chamber exuberates the “feel” of War in terms of darkness, chilliness, intensity, intelligence, and grippingness. While I was watching Chamber, I kept being reminded of War. It is one of the most high-quality costume production I’ve seen in a long time. In many ways Chamber is the perfect counterpart and is fitting and deserving to be declared as War’s 1920’s version.

For starters, exactly like
War,
Chamber is a female-dominated series with the women manipulating and plotting, totally driving the plot. The sets, props, and costumes of
War and
Chamber are both grand. There’s no question about
War’s set — what else beats the real Imperial Palace in Beijing? The costumes and accessories of the concubines were stunningly gorgeous.
War was a visually appealing and captivating series. The Sheung family mansion in
Chamber is massive with many rooms and a huge garden. In some “overhead” shots, it reminds me of a miniature version of the Imperial Palace. The 1920’s costumes adorned by the cast are also pretty. Both
War and
Chamber are glamorous alike.

No other series shows the repressiveness and power struggles of the women in
War like
Chamber. The concubines of
War were captive in the palace, unable to escape. They were bound by many codes and “laws” and life was a constant struggle. Their every move was watched. They could trust no one. They had to plot for power just to survive. If they didn’t, they would die old and forgotten, rotting away in the “Cold Palace”. They were truly miserable and repressed, unable to have any freedom. They were constantly on their guard and calculating something.
The wives of the Sheung household did not have much more freedom than the concubines of the palace. They were captive in the Sheung mansion, bound by their marriage to Old Master Sheung Hang (Paul Chun) and the Sheung’s “family laws”. They did not have the right to do as they pleased. Exactly like the concubines who fought for the favor of the Emperor, the Sheung family wives fought for Old Master Sheung’s (who himself is in many ways similar to an Emperor) favor. They wanted to secure their status in the family.
There was an internal struggle for power for the women of War and Chamber, but of course the stakes and measures were not as high for the Sheung family wives as those of the concubines. The concubines of War were held inside of the Imperial Palace by four tall red walls filled with ghosts and demons while the wives of Chamber were caged in the Sheung family’s “bird cage” of a mansion. Thus, the women of both series lacked freedom.

Chamber was deliciously captivating with all of its schemes and juicy dark secrets and twists. There’s lots of substance behind the surface and it is a dark and intriguing series and offers lots of think about and discuss, much like
War. While the dialogues and acting of
Chamber cannot be compared with those of
War, the script is simply too exquisite that it doesn’t matter.
Chamber is an excellent gem of a series that fits the War label snuggly. TVB successfully and unknowingly produced a 1920’s version of War. In fact, it is the only other series that TVB has produced in recent years that can even be compared with War.
More War to come?
War’s Producer Chik is trying so hard to recreate the magic, success, and intellectual depth and intrigue of War. I have confidence that 80-episode blockbuster The Gem of Life will be a “modern version” of War for reasons stated here . However, to be labeled or even compared with the War brand is a very difficult feat. Chamber was able to do it fatefully, but can Gem? I don’t want to put too much pressure on Gem [although pressure churns out diamonds so maybe it's a good thing], so I’ll just leave it at that.
Hope TVB will be able to produce more masterpieces like War in the years to come!